Results 1 to 16 of 16

Thread: analog delays

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    chicago
    Posts
    121

    Post

    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    412
    Posts
    285

    Post

    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.
    analogue delay just sounds far far better than digital. even the cheap ones. i love my electro harmonix memory man, which is relatively cheap and still sounds WAY better than any digital delay. plus having knobs and whatnot on it, you can actually PLAY the delay like an instrument as opposed to using a dial to set some numbers and then leaving it alone. its an entirely different experience, really. i reccomend you check out analogue delay ASAP........
    Never tell me the odds.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Netherlands
    Posts
    1,434

    Post

    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.
    analogue delay just sounds far far better than digital. even the cheap ones. i love my electro harmonix memory man, which is relatively cheap and still sounds WAY better than any digital delay. plus having knobs and whatnot on it, you can actually PLAY the delay like an instrument as opposed to using a dial to set some numbers and then leaving it alone. its an entirely different experience, really. i reccomend you check out analogue delay ASAP........ [/QUOTE]do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    they used to laugh at me
    but i saw the future

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    412
    Posts
    285

    Post

    Originally posted by O'love:
    do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    why would i do that when i have a real tape echo as well????

    ;)
    Never tell me the odds.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Netherlands
    Posts
    1,434

    Post

    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by O'love:
    do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    why would i do that when i have a real tape echo as well????

    ;)
    [/QUOTE]because you can run more than 1 intstance? because you can automate parameters? because it does some things the real thing cannot do?

    still, i envy you ;)

    Olaf
    they used to laugh at me
    but i saw the future

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    chicago
    Posts
    121

    Post

    Though it seems ridiculously overpriced, any thoughts on the moogerfooger delay?

    I have a minimoog voyager rackmount and I was thinking about getting a few of the other related pieces and a making a modular synth out it.

    How does the sound compare to a roland space echo for example?

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    412
    Posts
    285

    Post

    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    Though it seems ridiculously overpriced, any thoughts on the moogerfooger delay?

    I have a minimoog voyager rackmount and I was thinking about getting a few of the other related pieces and a making a modular synth out it.

    How does the sound compare to a roland space echo for example?
    i havent played with one since no music shops locally stock them and i cant afford to just buy one, but based on how nice my moogerfooger LPF is, id imagine it should be built like a tank and sound fantastic. tape echos sound much noisier than IC based analogue delays like the moogerfooger or other pedal based analogue delays.
    Never tell me the odds.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    NYC
    Posts
    2,006

    Post

    Though it seems ridiculously overpriced, any thoughts on the moogerfooger delay?
    Moog equipment just sounds great, it's that simple; better than most any other hardware available new on the market and comparable to used vintage brands that also sound great. The difference is that the real thing has no sonic compromises-easy to use, sounds good. Period.

    The nice thing with the Moogs is that they're new rather than 30 years old, but the older vintage pieces are also reliable if in good condition.

    When you get to comparisons between a Space Echo and a Moog you're talking apples and organges-both will sound great but different. You can't lose buying either one, or be willing to buy both to try for a while and sell the one you like less.

    If you buy used you can get better prices, or just be patient-the difference in quality will be worth it in the long-run.

    [ June 30, 2006, 08:21 PM: Message edited by: Free Russell ]

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    chicago
    Posts
    121

    Post

    Originally posted by Free Russell:
    quote:
    Though it seems ridiculously overpriced, any thoughts on the moogerfooger delay?
    Moog equipment just sounds great, it's that simple; better than most any other hardware available new on the market and comparable to used vintage brands that also sound great. The difference is that the real thing has no sonic compromises-easy to use, sounds good. Period.

    The nice thing with the Moogs is that they're new rather than 30 years old, but the older vintage pieces are also reliable if in good condition.

    When you get to comparisons between a Space Echo and a Moog you're talking apples and organges-both will sound great but different. You can't lose buying either one, or be willing to buy both to try for a while and sell the one you like less.

    If you buy used you can get better prices, or just be patient-the difference in quality will be worth it in the long-run.
    [/QUOTE]I agree, always get the highest quality piece within reason even if you have to wait a while to cop it.

    Thanks guys! I'll be looking for a good deal on an analog delay unit soon.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    chicago
    Posts
    121

    Post

    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    Though it seems ridiculously overpriced, any thoughts on the moogerfooger delay?

    I have a minimoog voyager rackmount and I was thinking about getting a few of the other related pieces and a making a modular synth out it.

    How does the sound compare to a roland space echo for example?
    i havent played with one since no music shops locally stock them and i cant afford to just buy one, but based on how nice my moogerfooger LPF is, id imagine it should be built like a tank and sound fantastic. tape echos sound much noisier than IC based analogue delays like the moogerfooger or other pedal based analogue delays. [/QUOTE]Have you checked out the murf?

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    55

    Post

    since y'all sound serious about your analog delays, i feel that the legendary echoplex bares mentioning (the original tape delay type, not some cheese 21st century gibson reissue).

    http://www.loopers-delight.com/tools...dechoplex.html

    http://search.ebay.com/echoplex_W0QQ...sopZ3QQxpufuZx

    to help put a sound to the tool if you haven't heard of it, this thing was one of the mainstays of early dub music (king tubby, mad professor, etc)

  12. #12

    Post

    Originally posted by O'love:
    quote:
    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.
    analogue delay just sounds far far better than digital. even the cheap ones. i love my electro harmonix memory man, which is relatively cheap and still sounds WAY better than any digital delay. plus having knobs and whatnot on it, you can actually PLAY the delay like an instrument as opposed to using a dial to set some numbers and then leaving it alone. its an entirely different experience, really. i reccomend you check out analogue delay ASAP........ [/QUOTE]do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    [/QUOTE]That plugin is awesome!

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Sep 2002
    Location
    London
    Posts
    1,172

    Post

    Originally posted by Craig Patane:
    quote:
    Originally posted by O'love:
    quote:
    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.
    analogue delay just sounds far far better than digital. even the cheap ones. i love my electro harmonix memory man, which is relatively cheap and still sounds WAY better than any digital delay. plus having knobs and whatnot on it, you can actually PLAY the delay like an instrument as opposed to using a dial to set some numbers and then leaving it alone. its an entirely different experience, really. i reccomend you check out analogue delay ASAP........ [/QUOTE]do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    [/QUOTE]That plugin is awesome!
    [/QUOTE]Did anyone compare the plugin with the original hardware?
    I am also looking to invest in some analog delay/reverb hardware and am thinking seriously about the Roland.
    Any feedback on this?

    C.
    "As for us, He has appointed the job of permanent unemployment.
    If he wanted us to work, after all,
    He would not have created this wine.
    With a skinfull of this, Sir,
    would you rush out to commit economics?"

    Jalaloddin Rumi

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Aug 2002
    Location
    Amsterdam
    Posts
    820

    Post

    Originally posted by Cedric Woo:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Craig Patane:
    quote:
    Originally posted by O'love:
    quote:
    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.
    analogue delay just sounds far far better than digital. even the cheap ones. i love my electro harmonix memory man, which is relatively cheap and still sounds WAY better than any digital delay. plus having knobs and whatnot on it, you can actually PLAY the delay like an instrument as opposed to using a dial to set some numbers and then leaving it alone. its an entirely different experience, really. i reccomend you check out analogue delay ASAP........ [/QUOTE]do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    [/QUOTE]That plugin is awesome!
    [/QUOTE]Did anyone compare the plugin with the original hardware?
    I am also looking to invest in some analog delay/reverb hardware and am thinking seriously about the Roland.
    Any feedback on this?

    C.
    [/QUOTE]Never heard that UAD...but you cannot go wrong with the Roland space-echo. Very versatile - great sounding reverb as well.
    LOVE it. LOVE it. LOVE it. You can even send some to an annoying flat plug-in synth and it will do wonders. Overdrive it and you will hear god. lol... A staple for Dub reggae as well.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Sep 2002
    Location
    London
    Posts
    1,172

    Post

    Originally posted by jordash:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Cedric Woo:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Craig Patane:
    quote:
    Originally posted by O'love:
    quote:
    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.
    analogue delay just sounds far far better than digital. even the cheap ones. i love my electro harmonix memory man, which is relatively cheap and still sounds WAY better than any digital delay. plus having knobs and whatnot on it, you can actually PLAY the delay like an instrument as opposed to using a dial to set some numbers and then leaving it alone. its an entirely different experience, really. i reccomend you check out analogue delay ASAP........ [/QUOTE]do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    [/QUOTE]That plugin is awesome!
    [/QUOTE]Did anyone compare the plugin with the original hardware?
    I am also looking to invest in some analog delay/reverb hardware and am thinking seriously about the Roland.
    Any feedback on this?

    C.
    [/QUOTE]Never heard that UAD...but you cannot go wrong with the Roland space-echo. Very versatile - great sounding reverb as well.
    LOVE it. LOVE it. LOVE it. You can even send some to an annoying flat plug-in synth and it will do wonders. Overdrive it and you will hear god. lol... A staple for Dub reggae as well.
    [/QUOTE]Hey Jordash,

    Thanks for your comments; that's all I needed to hear! I'll be on the hunt pretty soon ;)

    How's your music going? Looking fwd to hear some new stuff.

    C.
    "As for us, He has appointed the job of permanent unemployment.
    If he wanted us to work, after all,
    He would not have created this wine.
    With a skinfull of this, Sir,
    would you rush out to commit economics?"

    Jalaloddin Rumi

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Aug 2002
    Location
    Amsterdam
    Posts
    820

    Post

    Originally posted by Cedric Woo:
    quote:
    Originally posted by jordash:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Cedric Woo:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Craig Patane:
    quote:
    Originally posted by O'love:
    quote:
    Originally posted by pipecock:
    quote:
    Originally posted by dynomite8:
    What is the primary benefit of using an analog delay as opposed to plug ins? Is it simply a pleasing distortion added similar to tube preamps etc . . . or is there something an analog delay can do that can't properly be mimicked in algorithms?

    Just curious since the moogerfooger delay for example runs near $700.
    analogue delay just sounds far far better than digital. even the cheap ones. i love my electro harmonix memory man, which is relatively cheap and still sounds WAY better than any digital delay. plus having knobs and whatnot on it, you can actually PLAY the delay like an instrument as opposed to using a dial to set some numbers and then leaving it alone. its an entirely different experience, really. i reccomend you check out analogue delay ASAP........ [/QUOTE]do yourself a favor: check the RE-201 for the UAD dsp-card ;)

    Olaf
    [/QUOTE]That plugin is awesome!
    [/QUOTE]Did anyone compare the plugin with the original hardware?
    I am also looking to invest in some analog delay/reverb hardware and am thinking seriously about the Roland.
    Any feedback on this?

    C.
    [/QUOTE]Never heard that UAD...but you cannot go wrong with the Roland space-echo. Very versatile - great sounding reverb as well.
    LOVE it. LOVE it. LOVE it. You can even send some to an annoying flat plug-in synth and it will do wonders. Overdrive it and you will hear god. lol... A staple for Dub reggae as well.
    [/QUOTE]Hey Jordash,

    Thanks for your comments; that's all I needed to hear! I'll be on the hunt pretty soon ;)

    How's your music going? Looking fwd to hear some new stuff.

    C.
    [/QUOTE]Hey C,
    Just make sure that the tape itself is in good condition. New tapes can be found on the internet, but sometimes they arnt great.
    Things are goin pretty good musically. Thanks for asking. A couple releases coming up....Ill let you know.

    Have fun with the Roland!!
    peace,
    j

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •